Sign In
Sign In

Crude Oil Price Plunges 8.5% but Leading Oil ETF’s Gain Endured

HomeCrude Oil Price Plunges 8.5% but Leading Oil ETF’s Gain Endured

Crude Oil Price Plunges 8.5% but Leading Oil ETF’s Gain Endured

Crude Oil Price Plunges 8.5% but Leading Oil ETF’s Gain Endured

Oil Prices Continue to Decline While Oil ETFs Show Resiliency

The price of crude oil has taken a hit over the past 30 days, with West Texas Intermediate futures plummeting by 8.5% and dipping below its 100-day moving average. To put this into perspective, the largest pure-play oil exchange-traded fund (ETF), the United States Oil Fund LP (USO), has actually gained about 1% over the same period, despite experiencing significant net outflows in April.

This divergence between falling oil prices and rising ETF values is a striking anomaly that warrants closer examination. There are numerous reasons why oil-related investments are still faring relatively well, even as the cost of crude continues to drop. Understanding these dynamics is crucial for investors looking to navigate the complex landscape of energy markets.

The Resiliency of Oil ETFs

Oil ETFs have been among the strongest performers in recent months, driven by their ability to offer direct and indirect exposure to the oil market. These funds have benefited from increased demand for crude, which was fueled by a surge in oil prices last month. As a result, USO is now up 19% year-to-date, while the Energy Select SPDR ETF (XLE) has gained 16%. By comparison, the broader S&P 500 index has only seen a 7.7% increase for the same period.

Several key trends and factors have contributed to this resilience:

  • Growing demand: Recent price surges were driven by strong demand for oil, which continues to outweigh supply. As global economies grow, consumption of crude oil is likely to remain high, supporting prices despite declining supply.
  • Middle East conflicts and war: Conflict and unrest in key regions like Ukraine and the Middle East have disrupted production, further contributing to rising demand and constrained supply.
  • The U.S. dollar's impact on commodities: With the dollar remaining strong due to lower interest rates anticipated as soon as 2024, the relative value of oil will come under continued pressure.

While some market professionals like Tom Graff, chief investment officer at Facet in Phoenix, Maryland believe that "as we look at the possible scenarios over the next six-to-12 months, we see a lot more where oil is lower than higher" they are still cautious regarding demand issues surrounding wars and the economic growth performance.

Headwinds for Oil Prices

Oil prices will likely remain under pressure due to several factors:

  • Uncertainty around global growth: Murky outlooks on Chinese and European economies suggest that demand may continue to be a significant challenge, potentially outweighing supply concerns.
  • Strengthening US dollar: Until the Federal Reserve starts cutting interest rates, it's expected that the U.S. dollar will remain stronger, putting downward pressure on commodity prices.

Despite these risks, oil ETFs are not entirely vulnerable to falling crude prices due in part to their holding of a diverse range of oil producers across various aspects of the business spectrum. Nick Codola, senior portfolio manager at Orion Advisor Solutions in Omaha, Neb emphasized this point when saying that many of these funds hold companies whose production costs are around $40 per barrel, "making money as long as they can sell it above that."

This has led to some market participants becoming rather cautious about sustained downward trends over few months because they fear it will then pose a threat to those sectors and see significant falling revenues and margins as previous contracts go or are repriced.

Conclusion

While the price of crude oil remains under pressure, certain segments of the energy sector, such as oil ETFs, have demonstrated an unexpected ability to weather this decline. Several factors are contributing to their resilience, including sustained demand for crude, constrained supply due to conflict and unrest in key regions, and the strong dollar's impact on commodity prices.

As global economies evolve and new challenges emerge, investors should remain vigilant about these developments and the implications they may have for energy markets in general.